Ok, so the big desk does have advantages: storage, desktop space, etc. But in the small office it just took up so much space! Here it is:
See? It's huge. Plus the TV was way too high to be comfortable from the sofa. So we moved out the large desk and replaced it with the desk that I refinished and a hand-me-down TV stand from Matt's parents that we used in our apartment. I think it looks loads better.
We still have some trim to put up, and the closet door, but I think the room looks so much bigger with 2 smaller pieces of furniture vs. one large one.